It’s hard to believe that only four years ago, nearly every ad featured a limiting and often harmful message about women. From Carl’s Jr. to Go Daddy to Victoria’s Secret, brands told us time and time again that a woman’s value lays solely in her youth, beauty, and sexuality. This year, instead of ads that objectified women, many advertisements either didn’t have women in them or simply used them as accessories. Not only did most ads fail the Bechdel test, very few people of color were in ads or given speaking roles. Check out which ads passed as #MediaWeLike and the ones we’re #NotBuyingIt this year.
Women are HALF of the #SuperBowl viewing audience and hold 80% of purchasing power in the US. So what advertiser thought this was a good idea? Join us & @3PercentConf to live tweet #SBLII this Sun at 3pm PT & tell advertisers to do better! #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB pic.twitter.com/aN19hAqRs8
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 3, 2018
For the fourth year, we brought media makers and consumers together in a tweetup with our partner, 3 Percent Movement, to tell advertisers that sexism doesn’t sell.
How do you know if we’re #notbuyingit during the #SuperBowl ? Apply the 3% Test. What’s the 3% Test? So glad you asked.
1. Is there a woman?
2. Is she defying stereotypes?
3. Is she the hero? #3percentsb— The 3% Conference (@3PercentConf) February 2, 2018
@representpledge Ready to see some touchdown ads #mediawelike and call out the fumbles #notbuyingit as part of the annual Representation Project #3percentsb Hope to see some of my @KirkwoodCC students tweeting too! FB friends you’ve been warned! #SuperBowl
— Jacki Brucher Moore (@jackibmoore) February 4, 2018
The night started with an ad featuring Olympian Mikaela Shiffrin flying past the boys in an NBC commercial for the Winter Olympics.
Always be faster than the boys. @3percentconf #MediaWeLike #Superbowl commercial https://t.co/ZzEmCpbpjL via @ew
— Amy McDonald (@amyhmcdonald) February 4, 2018
The next ad from Toyota received mixed reviews. While it featured people with different abilities, it only included one person or color (at the very end).
Love this ad featuring people with different abilities @Toyota #MediaWeLike #SuperBowl #3percentSB
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 4, 2018
Hold the phone, @RepresentPledge. Did you notice there was only ONE person of color (and they were at the very end)? 🙄 Nah, @Toyota #NotBuyingIt #SuperBowl #3percentSB https://t.co/FIoLpGHLLT
— The Rep Project (@TheRepProject) February 4, 2018
@toyota Points for featuring strong women athletes in Q1 ad. Next time, more racial diversity for more points. #3percentsb #mediawelike
— susan parker (@2supersu) February 4, 2018
@Toyota just featured a disabled, stereotype-defying, and undoubtedly AWESOME woman in their #SuperBowl ad. Now THIS is #MediaWeLike. #3percentsb
— Mina Enayati-Uzeta (@menayatiuzeta) February 4, 2018
Then the team from Sprint gave us an ad featuring a female robot. But some of us had questions…
Hey @sprint robots don’t count as women just because you give them the voice of a woman #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB #SuperBowl
— Jess Weiner (@JessWeiner) February 4, 2018
Hey @sprint why does the robot have to be a naggy woman? Also #realitycheck, the only woman in your ad was a robot.. #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB #SuperBowl
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 4, 2018
Concensus from the creatives here in Boston at @hillholliday: @sprint ad FAILS the 3% Test. Sexbot doesn’t count as a woman. #3percentsb #notbuyingit
— Jenny Bergman (@yesjenny) February 4, 2018
Unfortunately, Budlight disappointed us yet again with a goofy commercial that relegated women to the scenery.
“They may have more men…” Goofy @budlight ad ignores the might buying power of women by relegating female roles to a few extras. #3percentsb #notbuyingit
— Staci Sturrock (@StaciSturrock) February 4, 2018
Women hold 80% of purchasing power. We shouldn’t be an afterthought @budlight. #3percentsb #NotBuyingIt https://t.co/k0GDwuj38Y
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 4, 2018
Dodge continued the trend of many brands like Pringles, that chose to have only one token woman.
Yah, who ya’ kiddin @Dodge #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB https://t.co/zSjFSa86N6
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
Nice to see that @Chrysler had their one token woman in the @Dodge Vikings ad #NotBuyingIt #3percentsb pic.twitter.com/0oEdv72pyL
— Parker Shea (@parker_shea) February 5, 2018
silly girls, trucks are only for viking men #3percentsb #NotBuyingIt
— Maranda Ryser (@marandaryser) February 5, 2018
Several brands including Wix and Pringles decided not to include ANY women in their commercials:
On today’s episode of Mansplaing… @Wix #notbuyingit #3percentsb pic.twitter.com/phqWINjKM0
— Parker Shea (@parker_shea) February 5, 2018
HEY, @Wix. Guess who is the largest segment of small business owners and first-time entrepreneurs? You know, the people who are most likely to use your tool to launch their sites? WOMEN. Yet you use two men as your spokespeople. #3percentsb #NotBuyingIt
— Jenny Bergman (@yesjenny) February 5, 2018
@Pringles where are the women? #creativecircusreferees #notbuyingit https://t.co/98C8T58UiE
— Christopher Vanderkleed (@van_der_Kleed) February 5, 2018
#NotBuyingIt Do women eat Pringles…or exist on movie sets?
— K Hauser (@KafiHauser) February 5, 2018
Dear every brand, advertiser, and media maker, women are your target audience. #SuperBowl #MediaWeLike #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB https://t.co/UIW7qNLFvp
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
45 minutes in, not a single female-expressing led commercial or film trailer. Unacceptable. #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB
— Christina Halaszyn (@cbucs_halaszyn) February 5, 2018
Mountain Dew and Doritos ad left us with one reminder: Everything is better with a little Missy Elliot.
Life motto: more @MissyElliott ALWAYS. #MediaWeLike #SuperBowl #3percentsb https://t.co/LmZDaZD25o
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
Morgan Freeman lip-syncing to @MissyElliott is everything we didn’t even know we needed. #MediaWeLike pic.twitter.com/qtcgfWLPxS
— NARAL (@NARAL) February 5, 2018
Diet Coke’s new ad left us wondering, why do advertisements continue to only portray only a certain type of woman?
The @DietCoke ad is PEAK problematic media in one #SuperBowl ad: if there’s a woman (and there’s only ever one) she’s white, blond, and thin. #NotBuyingIt #SuperBowl #3percentsb
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
And she wasn’t even a good dancer! Women of color have to be Missy Elliot to get into a Super Bowl spot! #NotBuyingIt https://t.co/7JxsgUtk8k
— Cristina Escobar (@cescobarandrade) February 5, 2018
In Ram’s Super Bowl truck ad, Martin Luther King Jr.’s voice was used in an ad called “Built to Serve.” This was one of the most tone-deaf ads of the night:
Can we stop with the commercialization of #MartinLutherKingJr? Seriously. #NotBuyingIt #3percentSB #SuperBowl
— The Mask You Live In (@MaskYouLiveIn) February 5, 2018
If only MLK could have been here to see his legacy culminate in a Ram truck ad. #NotBuyingIt #sbads
— Matt McDermott (@MMMcDermott) February 5, 2018
Um, I may still have a fever but did that car ad full of white people just quote Martin Luther King? ♀️ #notbuyingit #3percentsb
— Elle Graham-Dixon (@elle_sis) February 5, 2018
With the ads this year, one theme seemed to run through the entire night: representation. Whether it was BudLight’s medieval ad or Pringles comedy sketch ad, women and people of color continue to be underrepresented in advertising.
Quick Count: overall, have there been more dinosaurs than women in #SuperBowl ads ? #NotBuyingIt #3percentsb
— Shira Albagli (@ShiraAlbagli) February 5, 2018
Remember when Yellow Tail’s Super Bowl ad had the bikini girl asking to pet the guy’s roo? This year they just left women out completely. #notbuyingit #3percentsb
— Katherine M. Gordon (@katgordon) February 5, 2018
Women hold 80% of purchasing power, yet we’re only 3% of creative directors. Follow #3percentsb & #NotBuyingIt to see which #SuperBowl ads pass the test ⬇️⬇️⬇️ https://t.co/Ai7dipstYn
— The FBomb (@the_fbomb) February 5, 2018
Justin Timberlake’s Super Bowl Halftime Show received mixed reviews.
In the era of #MeToo and #TimesUp, surprised Justin Timberlake brought back “Cry Me A River,” a song and music video about stalking a woman. #notbuyingit #superbowl #3percentSB
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
However, there were ads that really made us smile and broke stereotypes:
Anyone else catch that the @CocaCola ad highlighted “he” “she” and “them” pronouns? Love it. #MediaWeLike #SuperBowl #3percentsb
— The Rep Project (@TheRepProject) February 5, 2018
Eli Manning and Odell Beckham Jr prove men dance. Deal with it. #MediaWeLike #SuperBowl #3percentSB
— The Mask You Live In (@MaskYouLiveIn) February 5, 2018
.@TiffanyHaddish‘s #GrouponAd is 💯🙌 — more black women with starring, positive roles in #Superbowl ads (and all media) please! #MediaWeLike https://t.co/kP5xEq7Jqg
— NARAL (@NARAL) February 5, 2018
I see u @CocaCola stepping outside the damn binary a little. Not terribly mad #MediaWeLike #3percentsb
— Girlboss (@girlboss) February 5, 2018
Eli Manning and Odell Beckham Jr dancing = new definitions of manhood and I LOVED IT. #MediaWeLike #SuperBowl #3percentSB
— Enayati (@AmandaEnayati) February 5, 2018
I predict that the halftime show and #NotBuyingIt are the Superbowl highlights.
— Samantha Ettus (@samanthaettus) February 5, 2018
Thank you for making your voice heard and reaching millions around the globe. Advertisers were listening! Remember, until there is equal representation at ad companies we will never achieve true equality.
Thank you for joining us for our 5th Annual #SuperBowl Tweetup with @3PercentConf #3percentsb #NotBuyingIt #MediaWeLike. What were your favorite ads?
— Miss Representation (@RepresentPledge) February 5, 2018
The #NotBuying and #MediaWeLike campaign will continue after the Super Bowl. Let’s continue to use our voices to call out sexism and hold the media accountable.
[button url=”https://therepproject.org/take-the-pledge/” text=”Join us” align=”center”]